Ep. 132 | What If Donors Don't Understand Your Calling? How to Explain Your Ministry

 
 

When God calls you into ministry, that calling is deeply personal.

Maybe you had an incredible experience where God spoke to you about what He wanted you to do. Maybe He opened doors you never expected, or led you through a season that completely changed the direction of your life.

Those experiences can be incredibly powerful. And because they mean so much to you, it's natural to want to share them with other people.

But what happens when you start sharing your calling with potential donors and they don't seem to understand?

Maybe they listen politely, but you can tell they're not particularly interested. Or maybe they question why you would leave your career, move your family across the world, or dedicate your life to this particular ministry.

And when you're depending on financial support to do what God has called you to do, those responses can feel pretty discouraging.

You might even start worrying that if people don't understand your calling, they won't support your ministry.

So you explain your story a little more. You share more details about how God led you to this point, hoping they'll finally recognize how important this calling is.

But what if the way you're communicating your calling is actually making it harder for potential donors to connect?

I want to share three things to remember when you're afraid donors won't understand your calling.

1. Focus on What Matters to Your Donor

Think about the last time someone shared a story about how God called them to something.

Maybe it was a missionary, a pastor, or someone starting a new ministry.

You could genuinely believe that God called them to that work. You might even find their story interesting or encouraging.

But did that automatically make you want to financially support them?

Probably not.

And that's something important to understand about your own fundraising.

Your calling is deeply meaningful to you, but your potential donors need a personal reason to care about the work you're inviting them into.

When you approach fundraising by focusing primarily on your own calling, it's easy to make yourself the main character of the story.

You're explaining what God has called you to do, what you need to accomplish, and how other people can help you fulfill that calling.

And while there's nothing inherently wrong with sharing those things, think about how that sounds from your donor's perspective.

You're essentially inviting them to become part of your story.

But what if you approached the conversation from their perspective instead?

What Does Your Potential Donor Already Care About?

Before you begin explaining your ministry, think about the person you're talking to.

What problems burden their heart? What situations do they wish they could change? What needs do they feel particularly passionate about?

Because your ministry exists to address a real problem.

There are people experiencing something difficult, and there's a need that your ministry is working to meet.

The question is whether that need connects with something your potential donor already cares about.

And if it does, that's where you want to begin your fundraising conversation.

You can help them recognize that you care about the same problem they do, and that your ministry is actively working to address it.

Suddenly, your donor has an opportunity to make a difference in something that's already meaningful to them.

Their generosity becomes part of the solution to a problem they care about.

This Is Why Knowing Your Ideal Donor Matters

One of the first things I work on with ministry leaders in my coaching sessions is identifying their ideal donor.

And there's a very important reason for that.

Your ideal donor is someone who already cares about the need your ministry addresses.

Think about how much easier it is to have a conversation with someone who already feels passionate about helping the people you serve.

You don't have to spend the entire conversation trying to convince them that the problem matters.

They already recognize the need. They want something to change.

Your job is to help them see how they can participate in making that change happen.

And that's a much more natural fundraising conversation than trying to persuade someone to become passionate about something they've never really cared about before.

2. Your Personal Calling Shouldn't Be the Main Focus of Your Fundraising Message

Now, I want to be careful here because your calling absolutely matters.

If God has called you into ministry, that calling is something you should take seriously. It can guide your decisions and help you remain faithful when things become difficult.

And your calling story can be a wonderful thing to share with other people.

But your personal calling shouldn't be the main focus of your fundraising message.

Sometimes, as Christians, we unintentionally expect other people to get behind something simply because we believe God called us to do it.

We share how God spoke to us or led us into a particular ministry, and we expect other believers to feel the same excitement and urgency that we do.

But think about how many people you've heard share their own calling stories.

Have you felt compelled to financially support every single one of them?

Of course not!

And that doesn't mean you doubted their calling or thought their ministry was unimportant.

God called them to something specific, and that calling was deeply personal to them.

Your potential donors may feel exactly the same way about your calling.

They can believe that God called you into ministry and still have no personal desire to become financially involved.

Help Donors Understand Why the Ministry Matters to Them

Instead of making your calling the central focus of your fundraising message, begin with the need your ministry addresses.

Who are the people you're serving? What problem are they facing? What's at stake if nothing changes?

These are the things you want your potential donors to understand.

Because when someone recognizes a problem they already care about, they can begin to see the difference their participation could make.

Maybe they're passionate about children having access to education. Maybe they care deeply about families in crisis or people who have never heard the gospel.

Whatever the need is, help them understand how your ministry is addressing it.

And then show them the role they can play through their generosity.

You're inviting them to make an impact in something that matters to them.

Your Donor Has a Role in the Story

This is one of the biggest shifts I teach in Story-Driven Fundraising.

When you're sharing your ministry's message, you want your donor to recognize themselves as the hero of the story.

They get to be the person making a difference through their generosity.

And your ministry provides an opportunity for them to do that.

When you approach fundraising this way, you're helping donors see the meaningful role they can play in addressing a problem they care about.

You can absolutely share how God called you into the ministry. Your personal story may even help establish trust and explain why you're committed to the work.

Just remember that your potential donor also needs to understand why participating in that ministry matters to them.

3. Recognize When Someone Isn't Your Ideal Donor

Now, let's say you've started focusing on what matters to your potential donors.

You've worked on making your message more donor-centered, and you're helping people understand the actual need your ministry addresses.

But you still encounter people who don't seem interested.

What does that mean?

Are you doing something wrong? Is your ministry message missing something?

There are two things I'd encourage you to consider.

First, Make Sure Your Message Is Simple and Clear

Before assuming someone isn't a good fit for your ministry, take a look at how you're communicating.

Are you clearly explaining the problem your ministry addresses?

Can someone easily understand what's at stake and the difference their participation could make?

Sometimes we make our fundraising messages unnecessarily complicated.

We use formal language because we want to sound credible. We try to explain every aspect of our ministry because we don't want to leave anything out.

And before we know it, we're jumping from one topic to another, leaving potential donors confused about what we're actually asking them to support.

One question I like to ask is:

Could a fifth grader understand your fundraising message?

Seriously!

You want your message to be simple enough that someone who knows very little about your ministry can understand it.

This is something I spend a lot of time working through with my coaching clients. We develop each part of their fundraising message so they know what to say and the order in which to say it.

Because when your message is clear, communicating with potential donors becomes so much easier.

Sometimes the Person Simply Isn't Your Ideal Donor

But what if your message is clear, you've helped them understand the need, and they still don't seem interested?

Sometimes that person simply isn't your ideal donor.

And that's okay.

You're going to have conversations with plenty of people who don't share the same passion for the work you're doing.

Maybe they care deeply about another area of ministry. Maybe God has placed a completely different need on their heart.

They can appreciate what you're doing without feeling personally connected to supporting it.

And you don't need to convince every person you talk to that they should become a donor.

Of course, someone who doesn't respond immediately may still be interested. They might need more time, have questions, or be unable to give right now.

But you can faithfully extend the invitation without feeling responsible for making everyone say yes.

You Can Leave the Response to God

This is something I really want to encourage you with.

Your responsibility is to faithfully communicate the opportunity clearly and invite people to participate.

You can't control how someone responds.

And you don't have to carry the pressure of convincing every person you talk to that your ministry deserves their support.

You can focus on doing your part well.

Learn how to communicate your message clearly. Build relationships with people who care about the need your ministry addresses. Give them a meaningful opportunity to participate.

And trust God with the response.

That can take so much pressure off your fundraising conversations.

Is Your Fundraising Message Focused Too Much on Your Calling?

Here's something I'd love for you to think about.

The next time you introduce your ministry to someone, pay attention to how you explain what you do.

How much time do you spend sharing your personal calling?

And how much time do you spend helping that person understand the problem your ministry is addressing?

Are you primarily talking about yourself and what God has called you to accomplish? Or are you connecting with something your potential donor already cares about?

Your calling matters. It's an important part of your ministry journey.

But your fundraising message needs to connect with the people you're inviting to partner with you.

When you understand what matters to your ideal donor and communicate the need clearly, you give people a much better opportunity to recognize the difference they can make.

And that can completely change how you approach fundraising.

Need Help Developing a Fundraising Message That Connects With Donors?

If you're struggling to explain your ministry in a way that connects with potential donors, I'd love to help you.

Through my one-on-one coaching sessions, we can work together to clarify who your ideal donor is and develop a Story-Driven Fundraising Message that speaks to what matters to them.

We'll work through how to communicate the need your ministry addresses and the meaningful role donors can play, so you can approach fundraising conversations with greater clarity and confidence.

Book a one-on-one fundraising coaching session and let's start developing a message that connects with the people you're inviting to partner with your ministry.

 

More Episodes

Next
Next

Ep. 131 | Your Ministry Stories Sound Like Reports! How to Tell a Better Fundraising Story