Ep. 77 | Your Fundraising Isn’t Connecting: 3 Ways to Turn Your Message Into a Compelling Story
You’re sending updates.
Sharing what you’ve done.
Highlighting impact.
Including numbers.
And still… it feels like it’s not landing.
Your donors read it—but they don’t respond the way you hoped.
Why Information Falls Flat
Most ministry communication sounds like this:
“We provided school supplies for 120 children this month. Thank you for your support.”
It’s true.
It matters.
But it doesn’t stick.
Because it’s just information.
And information doesn’t create connection.
What Actually Connects With Donors
Story.
Not vague storytelling.
Not something complicated.
Just a clear structure that helps your donor:
understand the problem
feel the weight of it
and see how they can be part of the solution
Here are 3 simple ways to turn your message into a compelling story.
1. Start With the Conflict
This is where most ministries hesitate.
You don’t want to sound negative.
You want to focus on the good.
But without a problem… your solution doesn’t matter.
Instead of starting with:
“We helped 120 children…”
Start with one.
One child. One moment. One need.
A boy showing up to school without a backpack—
carrying loose papers, some torn, some missing.
Now there’s tension.
Now your donor leans in.
2. Show the Journey
Don’t skip this.
This is where the story develops.
What happened because of the problem?
He started falling behind
He felt embarrassed
He didn’t want to come to school
This is where connection deepens.
If you jump straight to the solution, it feels rushed—and forgettable.
3. Land on the Resolution
Yes, he received a backpack.
But that’s not the real ending.
What changed?
He hasn’t missed a day since
He shows up with confidence
He’s engaged and learning
That’s what your donor cares about.
The transformation.
“But I Don’t Have Stories…”
You do.
You’re just not looking for them yet.
Stories are happening in your ministry every day—but you have to start paying attention.
And if you don’t have a specific story yet?
You can still use this structure:
What’s the problem?
What’s happening because of it?
What changed?
Even that is more powerful than just sharing information.
This Is the Shift That Changes Fundraising
When your message is just information:
donors forget
donors disconnect
donors hesitate
But when your message becomes a story:
donors understand
donors feel
donors respond
And fundraising starts to feel clearer… and lighter.
Ready to Fix Your Message?
If your fundraising hasn’t been connecting the way you want it to…
this is where to start.
With the message.
With the words you use.
I help ministry leaders clarify their message so donors understand it, connect with it, and say yes faster.
You don’t have to keep guessing.
Let’s make your message clear.
More Episodes
