Ep. 44 | The Nonprofit Messaging Mistake That’s Costing You Donors
Struggling to Write Your Newsletters so Supporters Engage?
You’ve seen God do amazing things- but if your emails are vague or unclear, your supporters won’t feel connected.
This free guide will show you how to:
Write subject lines that get your emails opened
Follow a simple story-driven format for every update
Engage donors with clear, Christ-centered storytelling
Many nonprofits struggle with fundraising not because their mission isn’t important, but because their messaging is unclear.
You can have a life-changing mission, a dedicated team, and a real, urgent need — and still lose potential donors simply because people don’t immediately understand what you do or why it matters.
When nonprofit messaging relies on clever titles, insider language, or vague slogans, it creates confusion instead of connection. And confusion is one of the fastest ways to lose donor trust and engagement.
Let’s talk about why this happens — and how to fix it.
Why Unclear Messaging Hurts Nonprofit Fundraising
In nonprofit fundraising, clarity builds trust. When someone encounters your website, a newsletter, a donation page, or a campaign title, they make a decision within seconds:
Do I understand this?
Does this matter to me?
Do I know what to do next?
If your messaging isn’t clear right away, donors don’t slow down to figure it out. They move on.
This is especially true for first-time donors or people who are just learning about your nonprofit. They aren’t insiders. They don’t know your acronyms, internal phrases, or the deeper meaning behind a clever slogan.
If they have to work to understand your message, the connection is already lost.
The Messaging Mistake Nonprofits Keep Making
One of the most common nonprofit messaging mistakes is choosing cleverness over clarity.
This shows up as:
Campaign titles that sound creative but don’t explain the purpose
Taglines that feel meaningful internally but confuse outsiders
Ministry or nonprofit initiatives named in a way that requires explanation
If you have to explain what a title, slogan, or campaign means, it’s not clear enough.
And here’s the hard truth:
You won’t be there to explain it every time someone sees it.
Your website, emails, donation pages, and social posts need to communicate clearly on their own — without extra context.
Why Donors Don’t Stick Around When Messaging Is Confusing
Donors are not just deciding whether they like your nonprofit. They are deciding whether they trust it.
Clear nonprofit messaging helps donors:
Understand the problem your organization is addressing
See how your nonprofit makes a difference
Know how they can participate and help
When messaging is unclear, donors hesitate. And hesitation kills momentum.
People rarely donate when they feel unsure. Instead, they disengage — not because they don’t care, but because they don’t feel confident enough to move forward.
How to Fix the Messaging That’s Costing You Donors
Here are three practical steps nonprofit leaders can use to create clearer, more effective messaging.
1. Define the Goal of Your Message
Before writing a title, slogan, or headline, ask:
What do I want the donor to do next?
Read more?
Click a link?
Make a donation?
Learn about the mission?
When you define the goal, it becomes much easier to choose words that guide donors toward that next step instead of confusing them.
2. Choose Clarity Over Cleverness
Clear messaging may feel boring — but boring is better than confusing.
Use simple, familiar language your donors already understand. Avoid insider terms, abbreviations, or phrases that only make sense within your organization.
If your nonprofit messaging feels meaningful internally but unclear externally, it’s time to simplify.
Clarity builds confidence. Confidence leads to action.
3. Connect Messaging to the Real Need
If your message allows for it, include the core problem your nonprofit exists to solve.
This is the conflict — the need that’s at stake if your organization didn’t exist.
When donors see the need clearly, they connect emotionally. And when they connect emotionally, they’re far more likely to engage, give, and stay involved long-term.
Clear Messaging Builds Stronger Donor Relationships
Effective nonprofit fundraising isn’t about being more creative — it’s about being clearer.
When donors immediately understand your mission, your message, and their role in it, fundraising becomes simpler, more sustainable, and more relational.
Clear messaging doesn’t just attract donors.
It helps them stay.
Want Support From Other Women Fundraising for Their Ministries?
If you want encouragement, clarity, and a place to grow in your fundraising and communication, join us inside the free community:
👉 Ministry Fundraising for Women Leaders
irisstorytelling.com/community
You don’t have to navigate messaging alone. Come be surrounded by women who understand the calling, the pressure, and the mission.
More Episodes
